When temperatures plummet across America, many homeowners discover their heat pump is not working as expected in cold weather. Heat pumps are praised for their energy efficiency, but winter challenges can cause performance issues. This article details the common causes, diagnostic steps, and solutions for heat pumps that struggle to maintain warmth when it’s needed most.
| Main Issue | Possible Causes | Solution |
|---|---|---|
| Heat Pump Not Heating | Frost buildup, malfunctioning defrost, low refrigerant | Defrost cycle check, inspect refrigerant, professional service |
| Blowing Cold Air | Reversing valve failure, thermostat settings, outdoor unit freezing | Thermostat adjustment, reversing valve check, clear outdoor unit |
| Not Turning On | Electrical issues, thermostat, low outdoor temperature | Check circuit breaker, replace thermostat batteries, professional diagnosis |
How Heat Pumps Work In Cold Weather
A heat pump transfers heat from outside air into your home, even in winter. It operates by extracting ambient thermal energy and running a refrigeration cycle.
However, when temperatures approach or fall below freezing, there is less external heat available, and frost can form on the outside unit.
This process challenges a heat pump’s efficiency, especially as most models lose effectiveness below 32°F (0°C).
Modern variable-speed and cold-climate heat pumps can function well down to -5°F, but many older units still struggle in typical American winters.
Common Reasons A Heat Pump Stops Working In Cold Weather
Outdoor Unit Freezing Up
The most prevalent issue is ice or frost accumulation on the outside unit. When a unit can’t defrost itself, it stops transferring heat efficiently, leading to insufficient indoor heating.
Prolonged freezing can also damage components, further impairing the system’s operation.
Defrost Cycle Malfunction
Heat pumps come equipped with a defrost cycle that temporarily reverses heating to melt ice. If the cycle fails, frost buildup can occur, shutting down the system or reducing effectiveness.
Common culprits include defective control boards, sensors, or relays.
Call 888-896-7031 for Free Local HVAC Quotes – Compare and Save Today!
Low Refrigerant Levels
Insufficient refrigerant makes it harder for the heat pump to transfer warmth. Low refrigerant can result from leaks or improper maintenance.
This leads to increased energy consumption, poor heating, and in severe cases, compressor damage.
Reversing Valve Failure
The reversing valve switches the direction of refrigerant, changing the unit from cooling to heating mode. If this component malfunctions, the heat pump may only blow cold air regardless of the thermostat setting.
Thermostat And Control Issues
Sometimes, improper thermostat programming or control board errors can prevent the system from initiating heat mode or activating necessary defrost cycles.
Dirty Or Blocked Outdoor Coils
Snow, leaves, or debris can accumulate around the outdoor unit, inhibiting airflow. This blockage impairs heat transfer and can cause overheating, short-cycling, or frosted coils.
How To Troubleshoot A Heat Pump That Is Not Working In Cold Weather
Check Thermostat Settings
Ensure your thermostat is set to “heat” and the temperature is above current room temperature. Replace batteries and check programming for scheduling errors.
Inspect Air Filters And Vents
Dirty air filters can reduce airflow and system efficiency. Change filters every 1-3 months in winter and ensure all vents are open and unobstructed.
Examine The Outdoor Unit
Look for ice, snow, or debris on the outdoor coil. Use a soft brush or broom to gently clear obstructions without damaging the fins.
Observe The Defrost Cycle
Listen for the unit switching between heating and a short defrost mode every 30–90 minutes. If the outdoor fan keeps running during heavy frost, the defrost cycle may not be working.
Call 888-896-7031 for Free Local HVAC Quotes – Compare and Save Today!
Test Electrical Components
Check circuit breakers and outdoor disconnect switches. If a breaker has tripped, reset it once. Persistent tripping signals a deeper issue.
Monitor Performance
Track how long your heat pump runs and whether it maintains your desired temperature. Extra-long run times in frigid weather could indicate refrigerant or compressor problems.
Effective Solutions For Heat Pumps In Extreme Cold
Defrost Cycle Repair
If you detect ice buildup, call a professional to inspect the defrost cycle, sensors, and control board. A functioning defrost mode is critical to prevent ice lock-up.
Refrigerant Leak Detection
Technicians can test for low refrigerant and locate leaks. Repairs often involve sealing leaks and recharging refrigerant lines, which restores normal function.
Reversing Valve Service
Problems with the reversing valve require specialized tools. If your system never blows hot air, a technician will diagnose and possibly replace the valve.
Upgrade To A Cold Climate Heat Pump
Newer systems use enhanced compressors, fans, and smart defrost technology. Consider upgrading to a cold-climate heat pump for reliable heating in sub-zero temperatures.
Supplement With Auxiliary Heat
Most standard heat pumps are paired with electric resistance elements or gas furnaces for backup. Check if your auxiliary heat kicks in when outside temperatures drop extremely low.
Preventative Maintenance To Avoid Winter Breakdowns
Annual Professional Tune-Ups
Schedule annual maintenance visits with an HVAC professional to inspect refrigerant, defrost systems, electrical connections, and air filters before winter hits.
Clear Debris Before Snowfall
Keep the outdoor unit clear by trimming vegetation and removing leaves. Consider a cover that allows airflow but blocks snow from piling onto the coils.
Call 888-896-7031 for Free Local HVAC Quotes – Compare and Save Today!
Replace Or Clean Air Filters Regularly
Dirty filters slow airflow, causing the system to work harder. This can lead to overheating and failure, especially during prolonged cold snaps.
Set Thermostat Programs For Energy Efficiency
Programmable and smart thermostats help minimize energy consumption and maximize comfort. Instruct household members not to override stable settings with frequent changes.
Recognizing When To Call A Professional
Unexpected Noises Or Smells
Loud scraping, grinding, or electrical odors often indicate severe mechanical or electrical issues. Turn off the system and contact a licensed HVAC technician immediately.
Persistent Icing Or Poor Performance
If you notice thick frost, ice sheets, or consistently poor heating after troubleshooting basic steps, professional diagnosis is necessary to prevent further damage.
Frequent Short Cycling
The heat pump should not start and stop repeatedly within a few minutes. Short cycling strains components and decreases lifespan. This issue often points to thermostat, sensor, or electrical relay concerns.
What Temperatures Are Too Cold For A Heat Pump?
Standard-air-source heat pumps are efficient down to 30–32°F. Below these temperatures, output drops, and auxiliary heating or upgraded models are recommended.
New cold-climate heat pumps can operate at more than 75% efficiency down to 5°F and continue providing some heat as low as -15°F. Consult manufacturer specifications for your model.
| Unit Type | Minimum Operating Temperature | Notes |
|---|---|---|
| Standard Air-Source | 32°F | May need backup below freezing |
| Cold Climate/Variable Speed | -5°F to -15°F | High efficiency in sub-zero temps |
| Ground-Source/Geothermal | N/A | Unimpacted by air temperature |
Should You Run A Heat Pump Continuously In The Winter?
Heat pumps are designed to run for extended periods during cold weather. Unlike furnaces, they work best with steady, moderate output—cycling off and on less frequently.
Setting a moderate, consistent thermostat temperature helps avoid system strain and unexpected shutdowns during cold snaps.
Best Practices For Energy Efficiency And Comfort
- Maintain indoor temperatures within 2–4°F of your target comfort setting—avoid drastic night/day setbacks.
- Seal and insulate ducts to prevent heat loss in crawlspaces, attics, or basements.
- Install ceiling fans in reverse to circulate warm air without increasing heating demand.
- Use window coverings at night to keep heated air in and cold air out.
When To Consider Replacing Your Heat Pump
If your unit is older than 12–15 years, frequently breaks down, consumes excess energy, or cannot maintain comfortable temperatures, replacement may be the best option.
New ENERGY STAR rated models are 20–30% more efficient and can dramatically improve comfort, especially in cold regions of the U.S.
Choosing The Right Heat Pump For Cold Climates
Look For Cold-Climate Certification
Choose a unit with a Heating Seasonal Performance Factor (HSPF) of 9+ and a variable-speed compressor.
Products designated as “Cold Climate Heat Pumps” by organizations like the Northeast Energy Efficiency Partnerships (NEEP) are tested for extreme winter use.
Confirm Sizing With A Professional
Improper sizing leads to short cycling and poor heating. Have a licensed contractor run a Manual J load calculation to match your home’s specific needs.
Consider Geothermal Heat Pumps
For maximum consistency and performance in any weather, ground-source (geothermal) heat pumps draw stable heat from below the frost line, providing reliable output even during polar vortices.
FAQ: Heat Pumps Not Working In Winter
- Why is my heat pump blowing cold air? — It’s normal for mild air to feel cooler than a furnace’s, but true cold air may signal thermostat, reversing valve, or defrost issues.
- Can I manually defrost my heat pump? — You can gently clear external frost, but internal defrost and refrigerant issues require a technician.
- Is it normal for heat pumps to run non-stop in winter? — During cold spells, long run cycles are typical. If the set temperature isn’t reached, auxiliary heat or a newer system may be needed.
- Should I cover my unit in winter? — Never block the top or airflow. Consider a snow guard or shelter to protect from direct drifts.
- How often should I service my heat pump? — Schedule professional inspection and maintenance at least once yearly, preferably in fall before heavy use.
Proactive Steps For Peace Of Mind During Winter
- Sign up for preventative maintenance plans with a trusted HVAC provider to catch minor issues before a cold snap.
- Track system performance using smart thermostats for early warning signs, especially on the coldest days.
- Consider enrolling in utility programs for rebates on cold climate heat pumps or efficiency improvements.
Timely troubleshooting and seasonal care can restore your heat pump’s winter performance. For persistent failures, trust your local HVAC expert for repairs or upgrades tailored to your region’s climate needs.